Dell PowerEdge R420 server review analyzing performance, features, and value in 2023

Description

Compact Design and Build Quality

The Dell PowerEdge R420 is a compact yet robust server that immediately caught my attention with its efficiently designed chassis. Weighing about 34 pounds and measuring 36 x 24 x 12 inches, it fits snugly into tight server racks while still offering ample internal space for upgrades. Its black exterior feels sturdy, and the overall build exudes durability. I’ve handled my fair share of servers, and this one feels built to withstand heavy use in demanding environments. The hot-plug bays make it incredibly convenient to replace or upgrade hard drives without shutting the system down—a feature that’s a lifesaver during busy workweeks.

However, I did notice that the design prioritizes function over aesthetics, which is common for servers in this category. While it’s not exactly an eyesore, don’t expect it to win any beauty contests.

Performance and Processing Power

With its Intel Xeon E5-2407 Quad-Core 2.2 GHz processor, this server delivers reliable computing power suitable for small to medium-sized businesses. I tested it under various workloads, including hosting virtual machines and running database applications, and it handled everything without breaking a sweat. The 64GB DDR3 memory is a significant plus, as it provides plenty of room for multitasking and ensures that even resource-intensive applications run smoothly.

The inclusion of 2x 2TB SAS hard drives offers a whopping 4TB of storage, which for my needs was more than sufficient. These drives are fast, and I noticed significantly reduced latency during read and write operations compared to older SATA drives. The H710 PERC RAID controller also adds an extra layer of performance and data redundancy, giving me peace of mind knowing my data is secure.

That said, the 2.2 GHz clock speed may feel slightly underwhelming for users handling extremely demanding computational workloads. For tasks like video rendering or high-end simulations, you might find yourself wishing for a little more horsepower.

Key Benefits

The Dell PowerEdge R420 comes packed with several winning points that stood out to me:

• The hot-plug feature simplifies maintenance and upgrades without downtime.
• 64GB DDR3 memory supports heavy multitasking effortlessly.
• 2x 2TB SAS drives provide ample, fast storage for data-intensive applications.
• The H710 PERC RAID controller ensures both performance optimization and data redundancy.

Areas for Improvement

Despite its strengths, there are a few shortcomings worth mentioning:

• The 2.2 GHz processor speed might not be sufficient for high-end computational tasks.
• Noise levels during peak performance are noticeable, which could be distracting in quieter office environments.
• The design lacks modern aesthetics, which might matter for businesses that value sleek server room setups.

Ease of Use and Setup

Setting up this server was relatively straightforward, even for someone like me who’s not a full-time IT professional. The instructions were clear, and the hot-plug bays made installation feel like a breeze. I particularly appreciated how the dedicated RAID controller simplified storage configuration, allowing me to customize it to my specific needs without requiring hours of troubleshooting.

However, I did find the initial boot process to be slightly slower than expected, likely due to the older generation of hardware. While this doesn’t impact day-to-day performance, it’s something worth keeping in mind if you’re in a hurry to deploy.

Product Rivals

When comparing this server to other options like the HPE ProLiant DL360 or the Lenovo ThinkSystem SR530, the Dell PowerEdge R420 holds its ground well. The HPE ProLiant DL360 offers a slightly faster processing speed in certain configurations, but it comes at a higher price point and lacks the robust hot-plug system found in the Dell. On the other hand, the Lenovo ThinkSystem SR530 is more energy-efficient, but its storage options don’t match the capacity and speed of the 2TB SAS drives included with this model.

What makes the Dell PowerEdge R420 stand out is its balance of performance and affordability, particularly for small businesses or entry-level server needs. While it doesn’t lead in every category, it delivers a dependable mix of features without the premium price tag of its competitors.

Affordable Quality

In terms of price performance, this server delivers excellent value for its cost. While it may not boast the latest technology, the combination of 64GB memory, 4TB of fast SAS storage, and the hot-plug feature makes it a solid investment for those looking to upgrade their infrastructure without breaking the bank. It’s well-suited for file sharing, virtualization, and database hosting tasks, making it versatile for various business needs.

Compared to pricier alternatives, this server offers a cost-effective solution for those who prioritize functionality and reliability over cutting-edge specs. However, if you’re looking for a server to handle the most resource-intensive tasks, you may need to explore higher-end models.

Overall, my experience with this compact server has been positive. While it has its limitations, the Dell PowerEdge R420 proves to be a dependable and practical choice for those who need a reliable, no-frills server for everyday business operations. The combination of hot-plug capabilities, robust storage options, and solid performance makes it a worthwhile consideration for small to medium-sized setups.

Additional information